Pros and Cons
Choice....
• No serious early onset diseases, but a carrier for phenylketonuria (a metabolic malfunction that can cause behavioural and mental disorders. Carriers just have one copy of the gene, so don’t get the condition themselves).
• Higher than average risk of type 2 diabetes and colon cancer.
• Lower than average risk of asthma and autism.
• Dark eyes, light brown hair, male pattern baldness.
• 40% chance of coming in the top half in SAT tests.
Deaf lesbians....
The end of sex?
By 2038....
HK and biotech boom
Can society handle designer babies?
In 20 years.....
Read more
Dawn of the designer baby?
Inequality on a biological scale
The Designer Baby Era is not upon us
The researchers, led by Shoukhrat Mitalipov from Oregon Health and Science University, had altered the gene behind an unspecified inherited disease in a number of one-cell embryos. These embryos weren’t allowed to develop for more than a few days, and there was never any intention to implant them into a womb. The story fueled another cycle of discussion about designer babies, and fears that a Gattaca-style world was just around the corner.
But the full details of the experiment, which are released today, show that the study is scientifically important but much less of a social inflection point than has been suggested. “This has been widely reported as the dawn of the era of the designer baby, making it probably the fifth or sixth time people have reported that dawn,” says Alta Charo, an expert on law and bioethics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. “And it’s not.”
Who did the experiments?
Shoukhrat Mitalipov is a Kazakhstani-born cell biologist with a history of breakthroughs—and controversy—in the stem cell field. He was the scientist to clone monkeys. He was the first to create human embryos by cloning adult cells—a move that could provide patients with an easy supply of personalized stem cells. He also pioneered a technique for creating embryos with genetic material from three biological parents, as a way of preventing a group of debilitating inherited diseases.
Although MIT Tech Review name-checked Mitalipov alone, the paper splits credit for the research between five collaborating teams—four based in the United States, and one in South Korea.
What did they actually do?
The project effectively began with an elevator conversation between Mitalipov and his colleague Sanjiv Kaul. Mitalipov explained that he wanted to use CRISPR to correct a disease-causing gene in human embryos, and was trying to figure out which disease to focus on. Kaul, a cardiologist, told him about hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM)—an inherited heart disease that’s commonly caused by mutations in a gene called MYBPC3. HCM is surprisingly common, affecting 1 in 500 adults. Many of them lead normal lives, but in some, the walls of their hearts can thicken and suddenly fail. For that reason, HCM is the commonest cause of sudden death in athletes. “There really is no treatment,” says Kaul. “A number of drugs are being evaluated but they are all experimental,” and they merely treat the symptoms. The team wanted to prevent HCM entirely by removing the underlying mutation.
Read more
Baby genes for sale?
Demand for designer babies?
how wrong most experts were about where the demand for IVF would come from: mainly from infertile couples wanting their own children, not fertile people wanting other people’s.
When will we have designer babies?
Designer babies fear
News articles - designer babies
- Controversy over embryo selection
-
Baby selected to be free from breast cancer gene
-
First baby free from breast cancer gene is born
-
Designer babies: The gene test
Genetic 'MoT' for disease free babies
Designer baby row over clinic that offers eye, skin and hair colour
Baby selected to be free from breast cancer gene is born
Brief arguments against embryo screening
The religious argument, spearheaded by the Catholic Church but also strongly supported by many other religious groups. These argue very simply that life begins at conception. An embryo is a fertilized egg, and therefore it is a life; embryo screening results necessarily in the destruction of embryos, and is therefore taking a life.
A further religious objection is that the selection of what children should or should not be born should be up to God, and people should not attempt to take a role in it.
There are many other groups concerned with the ethics of embryo screening. One of the most serious arguments is the concern that allowing embryo screening to progress to what seems its natural end will result in a global eugenics program, where prospective parents will be able to “shop” for the preferred embryo. The advocates of this argument believe that this will lead to “designer babies”, children born to fit a certain profile. And just as only the wealthy can afford designer clothes, this would result in a dramatic difference between the rich and the poor, as such on-demand screening is likely to be incredibly expensive. The rich, therefore, will end up with made-to-order babies, while the poor will be left to the natural order. In this situation, wealth will perpetuate wealth by breeding for it, and the low-income will become second-class citizens to a master class of tailor-made children.
DNA - the promise and the price
Read more....
Human Genetic Engineering is a step too far
Human genetic engineering provokes strong reactions. Dr David King, director of Human Genetics Alert, recently warned: ‘In a world first, the Government has said it will allow scientists to begin developing the technology for genetic modification of human beings, although creation of actual GM babies will be prohibited for the moment. We believe the public will be horrified’ [Ref: Telegraph]. The government move comes in the context of an overhaul of legislation on assisted reproduction and embryology designed to take account of the latest scientific developments [Ref: Guardian]. The spectre of eugenics haunts the designer babies debate. As one journalist puts it, the idea of designer babies tends to prompt comparisons with the Nazis, the hatcheries in Aldous Huxley’s novel Brave New World and the biological underclass of the science fiction movie Gattaca [Ref: Times Online].
While there are real concerns about what the future might hold, the debate requires separating fact from science fiction. The argument of supporters of genetic engineering is that fears are often exaggerated. Rather than crossing a significant ethical threshold, they say we’ll benefit from a continued improvement in our ability to overcome disease and improve people’s lives. Deciding who is right first requires understanding what scientists are capable of doing today. Then future possibilities need to be assessed. Finally, we’ll be in a position to assess what poses the greatest danger: that we take a step too far or that we fail to take the necessary steps towards further scientific developments.